Summary:

Sally's Job Issue

• Judgment: NTA
• OP offered Sally a job dog sitting, but she couldn't do it due to allergies.
• Sally is aware life is unfair due to being an orphan.
• Suggested alternatives like yard work to earn money, with presence of dogs.
• Sally feels she's being deprived of money Emma earns for dog sitting.
• OP acknowledges Sally feels life is tough but doesn't owe a job.

Sally's Allergy Issues Conflict

• Sally can't perform the dog sitting job due to allergies.
• OP seems unsympathetic and makes flawed statements about life being unfair.
• Considerations of kindness and empathy towards Sally's situation.
• Soft YTA due to lack of sensitivity towards Sally's allergies and life circumstances.

Meta Comments

• Some comments speculate on the authenticity of the post.
• Criticism towards the perceived attitude and language used by OP.
• Discussion on fairness, empathy, and addressing Sally's situation more compassionately.
• Mixed perspectives on whether creating a job for Sally was necessary or fair.

Overall, while OP may not be obligated to create a job for Sally, compassion and understanding of her circumstances are crucial in handling the situation.