Comments on The Watch adaptation of Terry Pratchett's Discworld:

Negative Views on the Adaptation:

• The adaptation drastically changed a character named Carcer, making the character more sympathetic instead of the irredeemable monster Pratchett wrote him as.
• Disappointment in how the adaptation altered key characters like Sybil, a middle-aged fat woman, changing her into a strong angry character without the depth of the original.
• Disgust at the showrunners prioritizing controversy over quality by making Cheery non-binary, despite the original character's explicitly female nature in the books.
• The adaptations failed to capture the essence of iconic characters like Sam Vimes, leading to anger and disappointment among fans.
• The showrunners undermined key aspects of the Discworld series, resulting in disappointment and frustration among fans.
• The disrespect shown towards the source material and the iconic characters in the adaptations was considered insulting to fans of Terry Pratchett's works.

Positive Aspects of the Reddit Posts:

• Despite the disappointment with the adaptation, fans expressed renewed love for Terry Pratchett and encouraged others to read his works.
• Users found humor in the craftsmanship of the negative comments made towards the adaptations, highlighting the creative criticism shared among fans.
• Fans appreciated the detailed write-up that showcased the shortcomings of the adaptation and united users against the poor treatment of beloved characters.
• Some users shared personal experiences with the Discworld series and expressed their strong emotional reactions towards the adaptations.
• The creative and humorous take on the disappointing adaptation brought entertainment and a silver lining amid the frustration shared by fans.

Overall, the Reddit comments demonstrate a mix of disappointment, outrage, humor, and newfound appreciation for Terry Pratchett's original works, highlighting the impact of adaptations on beloved literary universes.