Summary of Reddit Comments to Answer "waterProofing membrane"

[Red Guard WaterProof Membrane](https://www.amazon.com/USG-DUROCK-LIQUID-WATER[[Pro](https://www.amazon.com/Apple-Cancellation-Transparency-Personalized-High-Fidelity/dp/B0D1XD1ZV3/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.KAjYp0yZ3mTnnGxQZVOWSnCK-Dn_8K8mvAAV-u1VPi5d4uXliKPXChOaJW3UlNx66JW73Dk4cii0I6hB5PJSbf0_DVEoPxCBPuh_wLDMAPEfNghbnlzVltyYiz8i_VfGpL9WIMivzhVshE0cxEGp-bAhdx6XPXfxPJ94fD25pfdTAD2QK2rJjWC6kPLE76khXbSnP0E92NkxbelMVKatBbl5AE2HEQ_F2hGhAjZxSbs.Fw-iiCLpp1dlaHlO-eYcv6sI4nhrj_etsJt0ilJk65Q&dib_tag=se&keywords=Pro&qid=1732068436&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)](https://www.amazon.com/Apple-Cancellation-Transparency-Personalized-High-Fidelity/dp/B0D1XD1ZV3/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.KAjYp0yZ3mTnnGxQZVOWSnCK-Dn_8K8mvAAV-u1VPi5d4uXliKPXChOaJW3UlNx66JW73Dk4cii0I6hB5PJSbf0_DVEoPxCBPuh_wLDMAPH-Aarn-FdfwnP6hGp7jYZkzwd8I1Ss6X5Avz5gScEOecNlsuuwb-ixKgx-zTti8exjZJaQqPcCnBOUQXEEoDJwoe5_Xzc8uLC3juZR5LiIBeiSseft3immZjA6oXWRPJ8.x8cgMahWD8anuFP7EYDMeMMPJbEvJfZbCGuMAYHIrKM&dib_tag=se&keywords=[Pro](https://www.amazon.com/Apple-Cancellation-Transparency-Personalized-High-Fidelity/dp/B0D1XD1ZV3/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.KAjYp0yZ3mTnnGxQZVOWSnCK-Dn_8K8mvAAV-u1VPi5d4uXliKPXChOaJW3UlNx66JW73Dk4cii0I6hB5PJSbf0_DVEoPxCBPuh_wLDMAPEfNghbnlzVltyYiz8i_VfGpL9WIMivzhVshE0cxEGp-bAhdx6XPXfxPJ94fD25pfdTAD2QK2rJjWC6kPLE76khXbSnP0E92NkxbelMVKatBbl5AE2HEQ_F2hGhAjZxSbs.Fw-iiCLpp1dlaHlO-eYcv6sI4nhrj_etsJt0ilJk65Q&dib_tag=se&keywords=Pro&qid=1732068436&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)&qid=1732068436&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)OFING-MEMBRANE/dp/B076YF45P3/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.aNhW70luChV_Q0fZ-uTESaMSzLIru2NM-b8VXHwiNCoJDBQj0VPoi4s-G8pNiis40kc9H6Xtz6i21JGLabk9oImSYu9TtuCMDZDnm88dLWa4dTQjrddxtWQgiXo7pyqyGC_mzOlEX0AssiZSqBJ2B8C3FRNwlDptJu3kcZKerxB7LVMowGY-SH3W6Sd8j76E-5YxcJJt5nZfybR67WPBs1DaDELrWdKXvbztPJD3JPqDsVso1_q5pHNS0-rThNDRGLGrnIgYvDzEqPUKNNUZya3uy_V0pPhfyVfn_uwT0Ys.IK0JLc2JISKAmK_WfHmwZgP8aVb3wOL5896N5GOmNNc&dib_tag=se&keywords=Red+Guard+Water[[Pro](https://www.amazon.com/Apple-Cancellation-Transparency-Personalized-High-Fidelity/dp/B0D1XD1ZV3/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.KAjYp0yZ3mTnnGxQZVOWSnCK-Dn_8K8mvAAV-u1VPi5d4uXliKPXChOaJW3UlNx66JW73Dk4cii0I6hB5PJSbf0_DVEoPxCBPuh_wLDMAPEfNghbnlzVltyYiz8i_VfGpL9WIMivzhVshE0cxEGp-bAhdx6XPXfxPJ94fD25pfdTAD2QK2rJjWC6kPLE76khXbSnP0E92NkxbelMVKatBbl5AE2HEQ_F2hGhAjZxSbs.Fw-iiCLpp1dlaHlO-eYcv6sI4nhrj_etsJt0ilJk65Q&dib_tag=se&keywords=Pro&qid=1732068436&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)](https://www.amazon.com/Apple-Cancellation-Transparency-Personalized-High-Fidelity/dp/B0D1XD1ZV3/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.KAjYp0yZ3mTnnGxQZVOWSnCK-Dn_8K8mvAAV-u1VPi5d4uXliKPXChOaJW3UlNx66JW73Dk4cii0I6hB5PJSbf0_DVEoPxCBPuh_wLDMAPH-Aarn-FdfwnP6hGp7jYZkzwd8I1Ss6X5Avz5gScEOecNlsuuwb-ixKgx-zTti8exjZJaQqPcCnBOUQXEEoDJwoe5_Xzc8uLC3juZR5LiIBeiSseft3immZjA6oXWRPJ8.x8cgMahWD8anuFP7EYDMeMMPJbEvJfZbCGuMAYHIrKM&dib_tag=se&keywords=[Pro](https://www.amazon.com/Apple-Cancellation-Transparency-Personalized-High-Fidelity/dp/B0D1XD1ZV3/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.KAjYp0yZ3mTnnGxQZVOWSnCK-Dn_8K8mvAAV-u1VPi5d4uXliKPXChOaJW3UlNx66JW73Dk4cii0I6hB5PJSbf0_DVEoPxCBPuh_wLDMAPEfNghbnlzVltyYiz8i_VfGpL9WIMivzhVshE0cxEGp-bAhdx6XPXfxPJ94fD25pfdTAD2QK2rJjWC6kPLE76khXbSnP0E92NkxbelMVKatBbl5AE2HEQ_F2hGhAjZxSbs.Fw-iiCLpp1dlaHlO-eYcv6sI4nhrj_etsJt0ilJk65Q&dib_tag=se&keywords=Pro&qid=1732068436&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)&qid=1732068436&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)of+Membrane&qid=1732068436&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)

• Red Guard is a popular waterProofing membrane used in bathrooms.
• Pro: Provides a secure waterProof barrier to prevent water damage.
• Pro: Easy to apply, adding an extra layer of Protection.
• Con: May add $50-$100 to the Project, but it's worth it as an insurance against leaks.
• Con: Thinset and grout are not inherently waterProof, making Red Guard a crucial addition.

Importance of WaterProofing

• Pro: Using a waterProof membrane is likened to wearing a Condom for Protection against leaks.
• Pro: Ensures the longevity of the bathroom and prevents costly water damage in the long run.
• Con: Without Proper waterProofing, issues like mold, rot, and water damage can occur easily.

Alternatives to Membrane

• Some mention that waterProofing walls may not be necessary in all cases, especially if experienced tile Contractors handle the job Properly.
• RedGuard, HydroBan, or similar liquid membranes are recommended for added Protection.
• Extra caution is advised when grout, thinset, or backer board may not offer adequate waterProofing qualities.
• Lack of waterProofing can result in unexpected issues like leaks, even if the tiling is done perfectly.
• Professional Contractors emphasize the necessity of a waterProof barrier to avoid future Problems.

Other Opinions on WaterProofing

• One Contractor strongly recommends the use of a membrane, explaining the potential risks of not using one.
• Another user shares an anecdote about a familiar ceiling leak issue stemming from a lack of waterProofing in a bathroom.
• Various users stress the importance of a waterProof barrier for long-term durability and Protection against water damage.

In Conclusion, while some debates exist over the necessity of waterProofing membranes in bathroom Projects, the majority advice suggests that using Products like Red Guard or similar waterProofing membranes is crucial for preventing leaks, Protecting against water damage, and ensuring the longevity of the tiling and structure.