Summary of Reddit Comments on War Thunder

Gameplay and Mechanics

• War Thunder Anti-Air (AA) is effective against single planes in a slower-paced game where players have time to manually target planes. In comparison, World of Warships faces challenges with squadrons of planes and slow-firing guns.
• The addition of player-controlled AA has drawbacks, with concerns about deviating attention from controlling own planes for Carriers. Many players prefer automatic AA to focus on surface targets.
• Battleships have difficulty coordinating manual AA with other weapons, which may lead to targeting issues.
• The game lacks effective AA, upgrades, and captain skills that improve AA defense. The community suggests enhancing AA to make it more impactful against CV attacks.

Aviation and Vehicle Balance

• War Thunder is praised for its effective AA system, especially with ships like Des Moines and Helenas known for their strong AA defenses.
• The game faces challenges with BR balancing, premium vehicles causing issues, inadequate servers, and lack of new game modes.

Map Design and Gameplay

• Community feedback highlights issues of compression, economy struggles, spawn sniping, and stale gameplay in both air and ground modes.
• Air and Ground RB face problems with small maps, ineffective objectives, and unbalanced vehicle capabilities.
• Suggestions for improvements include better SPAA at mid-tiers, separate BR for planes in Ground RB, and addressing BR compression issues at top tier.

Challenges and Player Base

• Uptiers and downtiers create imbalance, while some planes are balanced based on their CAS capabilities rather than their stats in air battles.
• The player base is criticized for constant complaints without proposing solutions, affecting the overall game experience.

Quality of Life and Future Development

• The game is encouraged to focus on map/mission design, fixing BR balancing, and addressing complaints effectively to enhance community satisfaction and gameplay experience.

Overall, the Reddit comments offer various insights into the strengths and weaknesses of War Thunder, pointing out issues with game mechanics, balancing, community interactions, and development strategies. Players express a desire for improvements in various aspects to enhance the overall gaming experience.