Summarizing Reddit Comments on "VidIQ"

General Perception of VidIQ and TubeBuddy:

Many users find the free versions of VidIQ and TubeBuddy helpful for adding tags and keywords to videos.
Some users question the usefulness of AI-generated suggestions and coaching provided by VidIQ.
The primary complaint is that these tools may distract from focusing on creating high-quality content.
Some users feel the paid versions are not worth the money and the free versions offer enough tools for optimization.
Users express that these tools may not be as crucial in 2024 due to shifting trends on YouTube.

VidIQ provides information on volume/competition ratios of keywords and offers tools for optimized video creation.
The tool can help with SEO and keyword research, but some users express that content quality and engagement are more vital.
The channel reviews and breakdowns from VidIQ are acknowledged to be helpful and insightful.

The repetition of advice and clickbait nature of content from VidIQ is highlighted as a downside.
VidIQ and TubeBuddy are criticized for offering basic, common-sense advice and potentially selling user data.
Users mention that VidIQ and TubeBuddy are not essential and attribute their channel growth to other factors like content quality.

Some users credit VidIQ for helping them grow their channel and providing valuable insights.
Others mention that they've seen little improvement or even a decline in results after using VidIQ.
The use of VidIQ and TubeBuddy coaching services is discouraged by some due to the lack of advanced knowledge shared.

Users suggest using free tools like ChatGPT, Google Trends, and YouTube Studio for research and analysis.
Some users recommend creating custom tools for YouTube analysis and research, instead of relying on paid services.
Overall, many users advise against heavy reliance on VidIQ and TubeBuddy, emphasizing the importance of content quality and organic growth strategies.