Trane vs Goodman: Summary of Reddit Comments

Goodman:

• Goodman equipment is considered more cheaply made compared to other brands.
• It is associated with being easily available to inexperienced or "shitty" installers.
• Some users have had positive experiences with Goodman units lasting for years without major issues.
• Comparisons have been drawn between Goodman and Chevrolet, suggesting they have improved in quality over time.
• Pricing for Goodman units varies, with some users finding them to be a cost-effective option.

Pros:

• Cost-effective
• Some users experience longevity with Goodman units
• Available to a wide range of installers
• Improved in quality over time

Cons:

• Considered cheaply made with thinner steel
• May be associated with louder furnace firing
• Reputation for subpar installations

Trane:

• Trane is regarded more favorably by users for its overall build quality and reliability.
• Some users prefer Trane due to their positive experiences with the brand.
• Trane is seen as a superior choice by some commenters, even though labor warranties may be seen as lacking compared to other brands.

Pros:

• Superior build quality
• Reliable performance
• Positive user experiences
• Well-regarded in the industry

Cons:

• Parts may require extra modifications
• Higher pricing compared to other brands
• 2-year labor warranty seen as insufficient by some

Additional Information:

• Market availability and reputation of installers play a significant role in the performance and reliability of HVAC systems.
• Proper sizing, installation, and maintenance are crucial factors for the longevity of any HVAC system.
• American Standard, which is related to Trane, is also mentioned as a preferred brand by some users.
• User experiences with other brands like Carrier, York, and Lennox are also briefly discussed.
• The importance of getting manual J load calculations done to determine the correct size unit is highlighted.
• Some users recommend a heat pump system as an alternative to traditional HVAC systems.
• Prices for different brands vary based on the region and the specific equipment being installed.
• A focus on the reputation and expertise of the installers is emphasized as a key factor in the performance of HVAC systems.

Overall, the choice between Trane and Goodman ultimately depends on factors such as pricing, installer reputation, personal experiences, and specific needs for the HVAC system installation.