Summary of Reddit Comments on "Thomas and Friends Edward Gordon and Henry Episode"

Edward, Gordon, and Henry Episode

• Reddit users discuss the classic Thomas and Friends episode involving Henry, Edward, and Gordon.
• Henry refusing to pull passengers is a central theme in the episode.
• Some users reminisce about the episode's conclusion and how it marked the end of an arc for the three original engines.
• The episode is praised for its storytelling and iconic moments.
• The inclusion of other engines like James provides a well-rounded world-building aspect.
• Pros:
  • Excellent storytelling tying up a character arc.
  • World-building elements add depth to the story.
  • Iconic moments appreciated by fans.
• Cons:
  • Some users point out that the first two seasons lack clear explanations for certain events.

Fandom Discourse and Toxicity

• The discussion dives into the Thomas the Tank Engine fandom and the differing views and opinions within it.
• Different perspectives on adding new characters like Nia and Rebecca to the steam team are debated.
• Frustration is expressed over certain engines being sidelined for new characters.
• Pros:
  • Diverse opinions and discussions within the fandom.
  • Fans are passionate about characters and their roles.
• Cons:
  • Some fans feel certain characters are neglected or replaced unfairly.
  • Issues with character development and roles within the series.

Addition of Rosie and Molly

• Reddit users debate whether Rosie and Molly should be added to the main cast of Thomas and Friends.
• Comparisons are made between the personalities of different characters and their suitability for inclusion.
• The discussion expands to address the need for more character development and the role of Tidmouth Sheds in the series.
• Pros:
  • Exploring potential character additions to enhance the storyline.
  • Addressing issues with character depth and development.
• Cons:
  • Concerns over overcrowding the main cast and neglecting existing characters like Edward.

Additional Comments

• The conversation touches on various topics such as media recommendations for LGBTQ content and a user's comprehensive list of TV shows and books.
• High praise is given for the detailed compilation of LGBTQ media resources.
• Recommendations for fiction and non-fiction LGBTQ books are shared, expanding the list provided by the OP.
• Suggestions for LGBTQ films and novels are offered to enrich the resource list further.
• Pros:
  • Diverse recommendations for LGBTQ media across different formats.
  • Valuable additions to expand the original list.
• Cons:
  • Some missing notable LGBTQ figures or works may be highlighted by users.