Summary of Reddit Comments on Storytelling Open World Games

Favorite Open World Games Mentioned:

• Miles Morales:
  • Mixed opinions on its inclusion in top games list, some feel it's more of an expansion than a full game.
• Fallout: New Vegas:
  • Praised for being fantastic years after release.
• Breath of the Wild (BOTW):
  • Criticized for lacking engaging dungeons, hopes are high for improvements in the next game.
• Red Dead Redemption 2 (RDR2):
  • Described as stunning with detailed open-world exploration.
• Kingdom Come Deliverance:
  • Lauded for realistic world building and NPC behaviors.
• Yakuza Zero, Kiwami:
  • Mentioned for small-scale, dense, and alive feeling open worlds.
• Subnautica:
  • Praised for feeling like a genuine, interacting world.
• Skyrim:
  • Praise for pushing the genre forward and setting groundwork.
• Fable:
  • Noted for NPCs, character responses, quests, and world that react to player choices.

Interactive and Engaging Open Worlds:

• Detailed responses about creating dynamic, real, and immersive worlds in games like Shadows of Doubt and Outcast.
• Mention of Cyberpunk 2077 as an engaging, immersive open world despite game issues.

Opinions on Major Games:

• Elden Ring:
  • Reputed for size, exploration, and scope, praised for nonlinearity in a Souls-like game.
• Legend of Zelda, Breath of the Wild:
  • Divisive opinions on its open world, with some finding it lacking compared to Elden Ring or too repetitive.
• Witcher 3:
  • Mixed reviews with some finding it captivating and others not feeling invested.
• Assassin's Creed Odyssey:
  • Praise for stunning visuals and map design.

Discussion on Open World Genre:

• Interactive Open World Games:
  • Appreciation for games like Breath of the Wild enabling exploration without fast travel.
• Game Design:
  • Call for more scripted routes and high-density experiences in open world games.
• Open World vs. Linear Games:
  • Different opinions on the appeal of open world games, sandbox vs. linear levels discussed.

Humor and Comic Relief:

• Light-hearted comments discussing game characters' appearances and lengths like "why is keanu so small?" or "niggah like 4 ft tall."
• Humorous remarks on potential D&D involvement and online persona’s unpredictability.

In conclusion, the Reddit comments showcase a varied range of opinions on storytelling open world games, highlighting specific titles praised for their immersive qualities, engaging worlds, and storytelling mechanics, while also exploring concerns and preferences within the gaming community regarding open world game design and player experiences.