Query: Selfhosted best NAS

Immich

• Can create galleries based on existing files.
• Can handle videos.
• Considered an amazing Google Photos alternative.
• Pros:
  • Versatile for handling various media types.
  • Good alternative to Google Photos.
• Cons:
  • May overwhelm some CPUs during massive imports.
  • Developers might be perceived as rude by some users.

Photoprism

• Better for existing photos and structure, especially for Apple ProRaw.
• Considered slightly more polished than Immich.
• Pros:
  • Efficient for organizing and browsing photos.
• Cons:
  • None mentioned specifically.

Nextcloud Memories

• Works well for handling previews and thumbnails.
• Pros:
  • Capable of managing various media types.
• Cons:
  • Requires pre-generating previews and thumbnails.

PiGallery2

• Suitable for simple browsing, fast, and does not copy files.
• Includes maps and supports gpx files.

PhotoGuru

• Effective for managing both videos and images, but it is a paid service.

Pros and Cons of Other Mentioned Products:

• Pi-hole:
  • Pros: Blocks ads, speeds up browsing.
  • Cons: None mentioned specifically.
• Vaultwarden:
  • Pros: Secure password management.
  • Cons: None mentioned specifically.

Comments on General NAS Building:

• Consider factors like the number of HDDs needed and RAID requirements.
• The choice between mini PCs, Dell Optiplex, custom builds, or tower PCs depends on HDD requirements and power consumption.

Recommendations for Dashboards:

• Dashy: Easy to use, productive, and supports Workspaces.
• Homepage: Fits the bill for some users.
• Other options include Heimdall, UptimeKuma, and self-made portals like Web Portal Lite.

Email Server Recommendations:

• Mailcow, Mailu, Stalwart mail server, Purelymail: Recommended options for self-hosted email.
• Considerations include set-up ease, integration with LDAP, spam filtering, and AWS SES connection.

Notable Mentions:

• HitBoy, Large Pro, DJ Premier, and Salaam Remi are praised for their music production.

Conclusion:

• Immich, Photoprism, Nextcloud, PiGallery2, Pi-hole, Vaultwarden, and various dashboards are highlighted for self-hosting needs, with each having its strengths and weaknesses. Other tools like HitBoy for music production and Mailu for email servers are recommended by some users. It's essential to consider individual preferences and requirements when choosing self-hosted solutions.