Summarized Reddit Comments on Novel AI vs. AI Dungeon

AI Model and Features

NovelAI, also known as NAI, is praised for the Kayra model which is reliable but starting to become outdated.
AI Dungeon has been updating with new AI models and instructions, making it competitive in features and models.
Users mention AI Dungeon as better for a gamey, dungeon master, AI roguelike feeling.
Users appreciate AI Dungeon for its active development team and exciting future prospects.

Writing Assistance and Context Length

NovelAI is noted for excelling at self-contained scenes or short stories rather than longer contexts.
NovelAI requires consistent writing to maintain context but may need corrections and exposition after a certain length.
NovelAI offers a Lorebook feature for maintaining context and offers text assistance for actions and environments.

Text Adventure and Role-playing

Users find NovelAI helpful for writing descriptions and filling in between dialogue lines.
NovelAI is praised for its features like negative tokens and customized responses between dialogues.
Sudowrite is compared to NovelAI but users note that the choice depends on the writing goals and training data of each service.

Privacy and Security

NovelAI is favored for its commitment to user privacy, advanced models, and uncensored nature.
Users mention a breach of trust with AI Dungeon regarding data privacy, leading many to prefer NovelAI.

Other Comments

NovelAI is seen as better funded and more innovative than AI Dungeon in recent times.
Users express disappointment with AI Dungeon and favor NovelAI for various writing projects.
NovelAI is noted for better customization options and use cases compared to AI Dungeon.
NovelAI is preferred for its superior text generation and customization abilities.

User Experience and Recommendations

For text adventure games, AI Dungeon is recommended, while NovelAI excels as a co-writer and image generation tool.
Users appreciate NovelAI for its potential and features like Lorebook and customized settings.
The general consensus favors NovelAI over AI Dungeon due to privacy concerns and perceived superiority in text generation.

In conclusion, AI Dungeon is highlighted for its text adventure capabilities, while NovelAI is preferred for superior writing assistance, customization options, and commitment to privacy and security. Both have their merits depending on the user's preferences and writing goals.