Summary of Reddit Comments on NextDNS vs ControlD

NextDNS

• Users appreciate NextDNS for its reliability and ease of use.
• Features like custom rules, logging, and lower latency are highlighted as strengths.
• Some users find lack of development and missing key features a downside.
• It is seen as more suitable for individual users, offering more customization options.
• Setting up on multiple devices while still identifying them is straightforward with NextDNS.
• Ideal for those looking for deep customization and tracking protection.
• Users mention faster notifications, lower latency, and ease of setup with NextDNS.

Pros

• Reliable and easy to use.
• Custom rules, logging, and lower latency.
• Ideal for individual users with more customization options.
• Straightforward device identification setup.
• Deep customization and tracking protection.
• Faster notifications and easier setup.

Cons

• Lack of development and missing key features.
• Some users experience slower browsing speeds compared to ControlD.
• Development pace could be slow.
• Some issues reported with captive portals and Delta WiFi connections.

ControlD

• ControlD is seen as more business-focused than consumer-oriented.
• Recommended for those looking for easier profile switching and active development.
• Users appreciate the active development team, up-to-date features, and the proxy function.
• Some users prefer ControlD due to more features, better blocks, and easier profile switching.
• It offers a free tier for unlimited queries on multiple devices.
• Some find ControlD better at blocking ads and provide easier profile switching.
• Features such as default block list, improved performance, and transparent company are highlighted.
• It is recommended for accessing US services from outside the US.

Pros

• Business-focused with a strong emphasis on active development.
• Easier profile switching and active development team.
• Better blocklist, improved performance, and transparent company.
• Proxy function and customizable blocking options.
• Free tier for unlimited queries on multiple devices.
• Ideal for accessing US services from outside the US.

Cons

• Some users experience higher latency compared to NextDNS.
• ControlD may feel confusing and messy to set up for some users.
• Limited personalization options in the free tier.

Overall Comparison

• NextDNS is praised for reliability, ease of use, and customization options.
• ControlD is recommended for its active development, easier profile switching, and proxy function.
• The choice between NextDNS and ControlD depends on the level of control and customization desired by the user.
• Both NextDNS and ControlD offer solid options with different strengths and features, catering to different user preferences.

Additional Notes

• AdGuard DNS is also mentioned, offering limited queries even in the paid version.
• Users emphasize the importance of combining DNS with secure web gateway for better protection.
• Some users prefer NextDNS for its completeness and configurability, while others find ControlD more suitable for accessing US services and providing better block lists.