Reddit Comments Summary on Natural Shampoo

Traditional Shampoo vs "Natural" Products

Some users express skepticism about "natural" products, cautioning that natural does not always mean better or healthy.
A user shares their positive experience with Head and Shoulders shampoo, showing that not everyone benefits from natural products.
Another user mentions that they found their magic products eventually, which are more expensive and sulfate/silicone-free.
A comment highlights the use of Tresemme and expresses a love for sulfates and parabens, noting that what works varies from person to person.

Several users argue that sulfates and silicones are not inherently bad and that synthetic formulas have improved over time.
Some recommend going back to drugstore shampoo/conditioner, like L'Oreal EverPure, after trying high-end or natural products with no noticeable difference.
A user appreciates the results from Pantene after trying various high-end and natural products without success.

Users share various natural alternatives and DIY shampoo/conditioner recipes, including baking soda, apple cider vinegar, corn starch, cornstarch, and ACV.
Recommendations for soap nuts, Argan Natural Shampoo by Artnaturals, and specific brands like Mane Line Hair Care are provided.
Some users advocate for using soap nuts or creating homemade shampoo with ingredients such as castile soap, essential oils, and carrier oils.
DIY suggestions include making shampoo bars with ingredients like aloe vera, eggs, potato water, and nettles/rosemary/apple cider vinegar.

Users share their positive experiences with specific products like Calia Natural shampoo and Zuma shampoo and conditioner.
Some warn against products like Shea Moisture due to potential negative reactions, emphasizing the importance of individual reactions to ingredients.
Recommendations include brands like Giovanni Eco Chic, Garnier Hair Food, and Ethique solid shampoo bars, as well as Trader Joe's shampoo bars and Etsy for natural options.
Users highlight the importance of knowing factors like hair porosity, hard water, and scalp health when choosing natural products.

The Reddit comments offer a diverse range of perspectives on natural shampoo, highlighting the variability in individual preferences, ingredient reactions, and overall efficacy of different products. It is evident that what works for one person may not work for another, emphasizing the importance of individual experimentation and understanding one's hair and scalp needs when selecting natural hair care products.