Reddit Summary on "mbv"

My Bloody Valentine (MBV)

• The band is seen as the epitome of shoegaze, inspiring other bands in the genre.
• Some feel MBV's music lacks melodic structure and resonation.
• Fans appreciate specific songs like "When You Sleep" and "Only Shallow."
• The band's 2013 self-titled album is praised for maintaining the MBV feeling.
• Some users find Loveless overrated or have difficulty getting into the album.
• Fans have various experiences with live performances, from blown speakers to disappointing moments with Kevin Shields.
• Despite admiration for MBV, some prefer other shoegaze bands like Slowdive or newer acts.
• The band's impact on shoegaze is recognized despite personal preferences.
• Some users love MBV, while others feel the music is too loud or droning, preferring other bands like Slowdive.
• Kevin Shields doesn't consider MBV as shoegaze.
• The band's genre classification is debated, with perceptions of ethereal versus grungy songs.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Influential in the shoegaze genre.
• Unique sound that inspires creativity.
• Some users love specific songs like "Soon," "When You Sleep," and "Only Shallow."
• Their 2013 self-titled album is well-received by fans.

Cons

• Some find their music lacking melodic structure or resonance.
• Live performances may have technical issues or disappointments.
• Preferences vary, with some fans preferring other shoegaze bands like Slowdive.
• Debate over genre classification and comparisons with other bands.