Summary of Reddit Comments on Logseq

User Opinions on Logseq

Users love the concept, but express dissatisfaction with speed updates and changes.
Some users find the search function cumbersome and have switched to other apps like Tana.
Logseq is seen as creating a new app focused on databasing, similar to Roam or Dynalist, with bug fixes expected.
Users report slow development, buggy performance, and jumpy behavior but appreciate the app for short-term note-taking.
Mobile experience, syncing issues, and fundamentals are identified as problem areas.
Lack of communication from the Logseq team and slow development are points of concern for users.
Users are hesitant to recommend Logseq due to issues and slow progress in comparison to competitors.
Some users stopped financial support due to disappointments with Logseq's progress.
Users express hope for Logseq to improve in the future but are currently dissatisfied.
Logseq's UI is considered rougher compared to Obsidian which is viewed as more polished.
Performance issues and bugs with Logseq have caused some users to switch to Obsidian.
Some users praise the concept, philosophy, and design of Logseq but highlight disappointments with implementation and performance issues.
The upcoming Logseq database version is anticipated to improve performance and functionality.
Users appreciate Logseq's unique features but express concerns about stability and data loss.
Different experiences with Logseq include stability issues, syncing problems, and performance concerns.
Recommendations for alternatives to Logseq include Obsidian, Heptabase, Reflect.app, Capacities, Siyuan note, Silverbullet, Anytype, and [deleted].
Users suggest trying both Logseq and Obsidian to find the best fit based on personal preferences and needs.
Logseq is praised for its bullet-style outliner system, while Obsidian offers a wider range of customization and plugins.

Recommendations for Alternatives

Obsidian: Preferred for customization, plugins, and a smoother performance than Logseq.
Tana: Highlighted as a good option with a nice interface, but lacks offline support.
Anytype: Recommended for an offline-first experience, but may be cumbersome for some users.
SiYuan: Suggested as an alternative that works more like Obsidian or Notion.
Dynalist: Proposed as a suitable option for outliner functionality with good data portability.
ConniePad: Mentioned as an easier-to-use alternative to Obsidian with a rich text editor.

Other Insights

Users encourage defining success criteria before choosing a PKM tool and recommend evaluating options based on personal needs and preferences.
Logseq is described as a Roam clone with poor execution and a steep learning curve, while Obsidian is considered well-balanced but plugin-heavy.
Users speculate on the potential improvement of Logseq with an upcoming database version.
Siyuan note: Suggested as a possible alternative to Logseq.

Overall, the Reddit comments highlight a mix of praise for Logseq’s concept and design, but also frustration with its performance, bugs, and development pace. Users recommend considering alternatives like Obsidian, Tana, and Siyuan note based on individual preferences and requirements.