Hunt Gather Parent: A Summary of Reddit Comments

Criticism of the Book

Ethnography Concerns: Commenters discussed how the book lacked proper ethnographic standards according to anthropologists.
Parentification Concerns: Some users felt the book portrayed parentification in a negative light.
Romanticizing Indigenous Cultures: There were criticisms that the book romanticized indigenous cultures.
Monster Stories: Some users disliked the monster stories in the book, finding them unsettling.

Positive Reactions to the Book

Parenting Strategies: Many users shared that they found helpful parenting advice in the book, like involving children in chores and daily routines.
Autonomy: The book emphasizes giving children autonomy and involving them in daily tasks, which resonated with many.
Peaceful Bedtimes: Some users shared how the book influenced their bedtime routines positively.
Positive Experiences: Comments indicated that the book brought a sense of relief and perspective to parenting.

Bedtime Routine Discussions

Flexible Routines: Parents shared stories of flexible bedtime routines tailored to meet their children's needs.
Modeling Behavior: Modeling Behavior and helping children understand cues for tiredness was a common approach discussed.
Transitioning Out of Naps: Suggestions were made to transition out of nap times to establish smoother bedtime routines.

Easter Egg Hunt Debacle

Behavior at Events: Users described chaotic behavior and entitlement at events like Easter egg hunts.
Parental Competition: Parents were criticized for pushing children aside in competitive situations.
Public Events: Instances of public events turning into chaotic free-for-alls were recounted.

Ohio-Specific Comments

Specific Incidents: Several comments referred to negative experiences at public events in Dayton, Ohio.
Criticism Towards Ohio: There were derogatory remarks about Ohio in response to the described incidents.

In conclusion, the Reddit comments provided a mix of critiques and praises for the "Hunt Gather Parent" book, along with personal experiences related to bedtime routines and chaotic public events. Users shared diverse perspectives on parenting, cultural portrayals, and event behavior.