Summary of Reddit Comments on Etsy Products

Tips for Selling on Etsy:

Use SEO keywords in titles, descriptions, and tags to attract shoppers.
Consistently update shop with new products.
Research popular keywords on Etsy for better visibility.
Fill out shop profile and have a banner, profile photo, and shop story.
External marketing might be necessary to stand out among the competition.

Products on Etsy:

Digital products can be a good source of passive income.
They do not require dealing with shipping and can be a great way to earn.
Consider creating educational materials like games, coloring books, language tools, etc.
Find a unique niche to fill and consider using keywords to improve visibility.

Challenges with Etsy:

Etsy can be a challenging platform to break into initially.
Digital products face heavy competition and may require constant effort to succeed.
Dropshipped items are a common issue on Etsy, making it harder to find truly handmade items.
Customer service and offering tutorials with Digital products can set a seller apart from others.
Dealing with issues like delayed delivery and return policies can affect customer satisfaction.

Criticism of Etsy:

Etsy has faced criticism for allowing mass-produced items to dominate the platform.
Many sellers believe Etsy has strayed from its roots of truly handmade items.
Sellers are frustrated with changes in Etsy's policies and platform direction.
Lack of transparency and concerns about cheaply made products flooding the platform have also been highlighted.

General Recommendations:

Consider focusing on unique products that fill a gap in the market.
Avoid relying solely on Digital products due to heavy competition.
Look for ways to increase visibility through advertisement and social media marketing.
Understand the challenges of the Etsy platform and manage expectations accordingly.

In conclusion, while Etsy offers a platform for selling various products, including digital items, sellers face challenges related to competition, platform changes, and the authenticity of items available. Success on Etsy requires careful attention to SEO, unique product offerings, and strategic marketing efforts.