Discover reviews on "build diy home server like a nas" based on Reddit discussions and experiences.
Last updated: December 7, 2024 at 10:24 AM
Summary of Reddit Comments on Building a DIY Home Server like a NAS
Considerations Between Windows and Linux Based Systems
- Windows:
- More expensive, has higher overhead, history of forced updates and reboots.
- Less stable compared to Linux, poor data parity features, and drivers/software management can be less efficient.
- Limited native backup options, management requires GUI access, and not ideal for large storage drives or remote management.
- Linux:
- Simple, stable, and popular for server workflows and high availability.
- Recommended Linux-based systems include [TrueNAS](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOxEc1U-v52J_oCm_J6cm6tWpSj8d0-n2b9SELcBuLmLExrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqXxoJhQD9BbxcYD9vS2lWKVoZBQtSmp_m2d8FHnnsLyM.mnzkflFpl59D--8KqXmxYaFDdtlLLO0BHftUetPeVrk&dib_tag=se&keywords=[[TrueNAS](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOxEc1U-v52J_oCm_J6cm6tWpSj8d0-n2b9SELcBuLmLExrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqXxoJhQD9BbxcYD9vS2lWKVoZBQtSmp_m2d8FHnnsLyM.jgvS7V6SdW8RmdhZMqgdbdcSEe_pLF3mDgZKXJ1bp0k&dib_tag=se&keywords=TrueNAS&qid=1733567037&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOz3N4Yz-eDymwNRgzJhC6LKrVlHGVnGo6i_Fqo8jhx33BrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqrMeYBf5z3N2SqjzbpzS1Cxj8QNQzzJTgPjQcKoyBu20.tk0K4nI4F2aKUFf8WyYdoBm1r2-BbjHZBzDcFyKwK0I&dib_tag=se&keywords=[TrueNAS](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOxEc1U-v52J_oCm_J6cm6tWpSj8d0-n2b9SELcBuLmLExrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqXxoJhQD9BbxcYD9vS2lWKVoZBQtSmp_m2d8FHnnsLyM.jgvS7V6SdW8RmdhZMqgdbdcSEe_pLF3mDgZKXJ1bp0k&dib_tag=se&keywords=TrueNAS&qid=1733567037&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)&qid=1733567038&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)&qid=1733567037&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20) (formerly FreeNAS) and OpenMediaVault for NAS purposes.
- Linux distros offer better file systems like ZFS ([TrueNAS](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOxEc1U-v52J_oCm_J6cm6tWpSj8d0-n2b9SELcBuLmLExrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqXxoJhQD9BbxcYD9vS2lWKVoZBQtSmp_m2d8FHnnsLyM.mnzkflFpl59D--8KqXmxYaFDdtlLLO0BHftUetPeVrk&dib_tag=se&keywords=[[TrueNAS](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOxEc1U-v52J_oCm_J6cm6tWpSj8d0-n2b9SELcBuLmLExrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqXxoJhQD9BbxcYD9vS2lWKVoZBQtSmp_m2d8FHnnsLyM.jgvS7V6SdW8RmdhZMqgdbdcSEe_pLF3mDgZKXJ1bp0k&dib_tag=se&keywords=TrueNAS&qid=1733567037&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOz3N4Yz-eDymwNRgzJhC6LKrVlHGVnGo6i_Fqo8jhx33BrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqrMeYBf5z3N2SqjzbpzS1Cxj8QNQzzJTgPjQcKoyBu20.tk0K4nI4F2aKUFf8WyYdoBm1r2-BbjHZBzDcFyKwK0I&dib_tag=se&keywords=[TrueNAS](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOxEc1U-v52J_oCm_J6cm6tWpSj8d0-n2b9SELcBuLmLExrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqXxoJhQD9BbxcYD9vS2lWKVoZBQtSmp_m2d8FHnnsLyM.jgvS7V6SdW8RmdhZMqgdbdcSEe_pLF3mDgZKXJ1bp0k&dib_tag=se&keywords=TrueNAS&qid=1733567037&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)&qid=1733567038&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)&qid=1733567037&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)) or BTRFS (Synology, Unraid) for data parity and robust RAID configurations.
Suggestions on Best OS for NAS Setup
- Synology:
- Synology devices like DS723+ and DS923+ are recommended for ease of use and robust storage features.
- [TrueNAS](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOxEc1U-v52J_oCm_J6cm6tWpSj8d0-n2b9SELcBuLmLExrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqXxoJhQD9BbxcYD9vS2lWKVoZBQtSmp_m2d8FHnnsLyM.mnzkflFpl59D--8KqXmxYaFDdtlLLO0BHftUetPeVrk&dib_tag=se&keywords=[[TrueNAS](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOxEc1U-v52J_oCm_J6cm6tWpSj8d0-n2b9SELcBuLmLExrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqXxoJhQD9BbxcYD9vS2lWKVoZBQtSmp_m2d8FHnnsLyM.jgvS7V6SdW8RmdhZMqgdbdcSEe_pLF3mDgZKXJ1bp0k&dib_tag=se&keywords=TrueNAS&qid=1733567037&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOz3N4Yz-eDymwNRgzJhC6LKrVlHGVnGo6i_Fqo8jhx33BrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqrMeYBf5z3N2SqjzbpzS1Cxj8QNQzzJTgPjQcKoyBu20.tk0K4nI4F2aKUFf8WyYdoBm1r2-BbjHZBzDcFyKwK0I&dib_tag=se&keywords=[TrueNAS](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOxEc1U-v52J_oCm_J6cm6tWpSj8d0-n2b9SELcBuLmLExrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqXxoJhQD9BbxcYD9vS2lWKVoZBQtSmp_m2d8FHnnsLyM.jgvS7V6SdW8RmdhZMqgdbdcSEe_pLF3mDgZKXJ1bp0k&dib_tag=se&keywords=TrueNAS&qid=1733567037&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)&qid=1733567038&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)&qid=1733567037&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20):
- Ideal for users looking for a NAS OS that supports ZFS-based solutions and offers robust data management.
- Proxmox:
- Suggested for those interested in virtualization and managing VMs and containers along with a home server setup.
- Unraid:
- Suited for beginners with a user-friendly interface and flexibility in managing apps.
- OpenMediaVault:
- Offers a web interface for managing storage and network shares, suitable for those seeking simplicity.
Other Suggestions
- Consider separating your router/firewall from the NAS setup for easier troubleshooting.
- Ensure to plan for storage expansion and use compatible hardware components for efficiency.
- Look into Synology, [TrueNAS](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOxEc1U-v52J_oCm_J6cm6tWpSj8d0-n2b9SELcBuLmLExrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqXxoJhQD9BbxcYD9vS2lWKVoZBQtSmp_m2d8FHnnsLyM.mnzkflFpl59D--8KqXmxYaFDdtlLLO0BHftUetPeVrk&dib_tag=se&keywords=[[TrueNAS](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOxEc1U-v52J_oCm_J6cm6tWpSj8d0-n2b9SELcBuLmLExrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqXxoJhQD9BbxcYD9vS2lWKVoZBQtSmp_m2d8FHnnsLyM.jgvS7V6SdW8RmdhZMqgdbdcSEe_pLF3mDgZKXJ1bp0k&dib_tag=se&keywords=TrueNAS&qid=1733567037&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOz3N4Yz-eDymwNRgzJhC6LKrVlHGVnGo6i_Fqo8jhx33BrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqrMeYBf5z3N2SqjzbpzS1Cxj8QNQzzJTgPjQcKoyBu20.tk0K4nI4F2aKUFf8WyYdoBm1r2-BbjHZBzDcFyKwK0I&dib_tag=se&keywords=[TrueNAS](https://www.amazon.com/iXsystems-Mini-X-Diskless/dp/B08FCWBVWX/ref=sr_1_1?dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.sJAHjlFrmf8hDe91jwkEnv5mKbPm6AfPevcCZHKktfIFBMTt_5uS1RkekYYge3Xsvd4FI4P7Ag1harjjJK_ZVjJ7Mb1bf7uqC6vJYGcafOxEc1U-v52J_oCm_J6cm6tWpSj8d0-n2b9SELcBuLmLExrXoU4Z9Bzj-mIV_NN0qGBuPh9cd2uKfJYX5bDtYMuqXxoJhQD9BbxcYD9vS2lWKVoZBQtSmp_m2d8FHnnsLyM.jgvS7V6SdW8RmdhZMqgdbdcSEe_pLF3mDgZKXJ1bp0k&dib_tag=se&keywords=TrueNAS&qid=1733567037&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)&qid=1733567038&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20)&qid=1733567037&sr=8-1&tag=redditrevie08-20), and Proxmox for different functionalities based on your needs and level of expertise.
- Explore resources like XDA Developers for guides and tutorials on setting up a DIY home server from an old laptop.
- Ensure you have adequate RAM, storage, and efficiency in your build to meet your current and potential future home server needs.
Overall, the choice between Windows and Linux-based systems, as well as selecting the right OS for your NAS build, will depend on your preferences, experience level, and desired functionalities.
