Summary of Reddit Comments on "Breath of Fire":

Overall Sentiment:

• Comments show a mix of opinions regarding the different games in the Breath of Fire series.
• "Breath of Fire 3" and "Breath of Fire 4" are generally well-received and considered favorites by many.
• The series is often said to have deteriorated post "Breath of Fire 4," with some finding later entries disappointing.
• "Breath of Fire 2" is highlighted for its gameplay improvements over the first game.
• There are differing opinions on "Breath of Fire 1," with some feeling it has aged poorly.
• "Breath of Fire 5," also known as "Dragon Quarter," is considered experimental and divisive among fans.
• The series is often praised for its music, art style, and distinctive features like the fusion system, dragon transformations, and character designs.
• The less positive aspects mentioned include high encounter rates, dated mechanics, rough translations, and pacing issues in some installments.

Individual Summaries:

Breath of Fire 1:

• Pros:
  • It offers a classic JRPG experience.
  • Notable for being the first entry with innovative ideas.
• Cons:
  • Some mention it has not aged well compared to other games of its time.

Breath of Fire 2:

• Pros:
  • Praised for solid story plot, gameplay, and improvements over the first game.
  • The religious aspects may not appeal to all, but overall enjoyment is noted.

Breath of Fire 3:

• Pros:
  • Often hailed as one of the best in the series with engaging features.
• Cons:
  • Some mention pacing issues towards the end.

Breath of Fire 4:

• Pros:
  • Known for its distinctive story elements and characterizations.
• Cons:
  • Slow and boring beginning is criticized by some.

Breath of Fire 5 (Dragon Quarter):

• Pros:
  • Appreciated for its dungeon crawler and RTS elements.
• Cons:
  • The timed combat system is polarizing and differs significantly from previous entries.

Recommendations:

• Starting Point: "Breath of Fire 3" is often recommended as a strong entry point due to its overall quality.
• Skippable: Opinions vary on whether to skip "Breath of Fire 1," with focus shifting towards the stronger sequels.
• Remasters: Fans express interest in remastered collections for modern platforms.
• Overall Legacy: Despite varying opinions on individual titles, the series is commended for its unique charm and contributions to the JRPG genre.

In conclusion, Reddit users have shared diverse perspectives on the Breath of Fire series, highlighting both its strengths and weaknesses across different installments, with a focus on gameplay, storytelling, and overall appeal.