Best Winter Running Shoe Recommendations from Reddit Comments

Brooks Cascadia

• Pros:
  • Good amount of grip
  • Bigger lugs suitable for muddy and chalky terrains
• Cons:
  • GTX version may lead to sweaty feet and lack of drying

Salomon

• Pros:
  • Not breathable, great for cold weather
  • Offers good tread for slippery ice and snow
• Cons:
  • Might not provide enough warmth in extreme cold

Merrell, Keen, Columbia, Sorel

• Pros:
  • Water-resistant hiker type athletic shoes
  • Decent tread for wet, snowy, or slippery conditions
• Cons:
  • Some models may not offer sufficient insulation for very cold temperatures

Vessi

• Pros:
  • Waterproof ankle-high slip-ons
• Cons:
  • Limited styles available

Danner

• Pros:
  • Known for making quality boots
• Cons:
  • Limited information provided in the comments

Blundstone Boots

• Pros:
  • Stylish, versatile, and comfortable
• Cons:
  • Not insulated, may require additional layering in extreme cold

Uggs

• Pros:
  • Extremely comfortable and stylish
• Cons:
  • Might not be ideal for heavy winter use without insulation

Hushpuppies

• Pros:
  • Waterproof, insulated, and stylish
• Cons:
  • May not be suitable for hot weather

Allbirds (Wool)

• Pros:
  • Kept feet warm and dry in winter
• Cons:
  • Limited information on performance in extreme conditions

Timberland (Timbs)

• Pros:
  • Known for being sturdy and durable
• Cons:
  • Safety boots may not be ideal for running

New Balance

• Pros:
  • Comfy smart-casual runner shoes preferred by some users
• Cons:
  • May not provide enough support for trail running

Decathlon TR2

• Pros:
  • Well-rounded trail shoes suitable for mixed terrain
• Cons:
  • Limited information provided on long-term performance

Saucony Peregrines

• Pros:
  • Handled British winter conditions well
• Cons:
  • Goretex versions may hold water
  • 4mm drop might not suit everyone

Inov8 Trailfly

• Pros:
  • Wide toe box, lightweight, cushioned, responsive
• Cons:
  • Adjustment period needed for zero-drop design

Altras

• Pros:
  • Not specified in comments

Based on the Reddit comments, Brooks Cascadia, Salomon, Merrell, Keen, Columbia, Sorel, and other brands like Vessi, Danner, Blundstone, Uggs, Hushpuppies, Allbirds, and Timberland are popular choices for winter running shoes. Users highlighted features such as grip, insulation, water-resistance, and comfort as key factors in selecting the best shoes for running in cold weather. Note: Altras, Saucony Peregrines, and Inov8 Trailfly were also mentioned as suitable options for winter running.