Best Pool Pump Recommendations from Reddit Comments

Hayward Super Pump

• Pros:
  • User mentioned, "I have the same pump and just replaced the motor couple weeks ago."
  • Compatible with different types of motors.
• Cons:
  • Some users suggested it is better to have a professional replace the motor to avoid voiding the warranty.

EVO130 Variable Speed Pump

• Pros:
  • User recommended, "Call and get a quote for the EVO130. It's a variable speed replacement motor with 3 year warranty."
  • Offers energy efficiency and potential cost savings.
• Cons:
  • No significant cons mentioned in the comments.

B&D 3HP Variable Speed Pump

• Pros:
  • User stated, "I chose to replace my pump with a B&D 3HP VSP which cost about 1/2 of the popular brand names."
• Cons:
  • No major cons mentioned in the comments.

MEDAS 1HP 3434 GPH Sump Pump

• Pros:
  • Recommended by users for draining and refilling pools quickly.
• Cons:
  • Sump pumps may take longer to drain the pool compared to other methods like using a hose and siphon action.

Overall, it seems like the Hayward Super Pump is a popular choice among users for its reliability and compatibility with different motors. The EVO130 Variable Speed Pump and B&D 3HP Variable Speed Pump are also good options for those looking for energy efficiency and cost savings in the long run.