Best Ice Cream Recommendations from Reddit Comments

Tillamook Ice Cream

Highly praised for a variety of flavors and overall quality
Known for flavors like Oregon Dark Cherry and Mudslide

Haagen Dazs Vanilla Bean

Haagen Dazs Vanilla Bean specifically mentioned for its perfection in flavor
Mentioned as a classic and top choice for many

Jeni's Ice Cream

Flavor recommendations include Gooey Butter Cake, Brown Butter Almond Brittle, and Brambleberry Crisp
Some users prefer Jeni's for its unique and flavorful options

Kirkland Super Premium Vanilla Ice Cream

Praised for its quality and taste, especially considering its affordability

Costco's Kirkland Vanilla Ice Cream

Considered one of the best ice cream options available at a store

Blue Bell Ice Cream

Mentioned positively for flavors like Cookies 'n Cream and Strawberry
Some users caution about past sanitation violations but still express love for the brand

Perry's and Byrne Dairy

Regional favorites for flavors like cannoli and general quality

Ben & Jerry's Ice Cream

Well-regarded for flavors like Peanut Butter Cup and Brazilian Rainforest Crunch

Private Selection from Kroger

Specifically mentioned for Tres Leches Cake ice cream flavor

Magnum Ice Cream

A favorite for its quality and delicious flavors

Turkey Hill Ice Cream

The Chocolate Trio flavor is a favorite for some users

Baskin Robbins & Breyers Ice Cream

Popular brands mentioned for various flavors like Cotton Candy and Vanilla Bean

Graeter's Ice Cream

Highly desired by users for its premium quality, but availability may vary

Other Local and Artisanal Brands

Recommendations include Annie Rue, Made By Marcus, Kind, Yelo'd, and Twice Cream
Local favorites mentioned from various small batch shops with unique and creative flavors

Miscellaneous Ice Cream Shops

Recommendations range from local spots like Gelati Celesti in Richmond to Thrifty to various Los Angeles establishments like McConnells, Salt & Straw, and Fosselmans

In summary, the Reddit comments highlighted a diverse range of ice cream brands and flavors, with popular choices including Tillamook, Haagen Dazs Vanilla Bean, Jeni's, Kirkland Super Premium, and Blue Bell. Local and artisanal brands like Annie Rue and Made By Marcus were also highly praised. Users appreciated unique flavors, quality ingredients, and overall deliciousness in their ice cream choices.