Best Hot Beef Sandwich in Chicago

Johnnie's

• Users strongly support Johnnie's as the top choice for Italian beef in Chicago.
• Comments mention that Johnnie's is hands down the best beef in the Chicagoland area.
• There is a strong sentiment that Johnnie's should be ranked number one.
• It is pointed out that Johnnie's should remain at the top spot as it excels in flavor and quality.

Al's Italian Beef

• While opinions vary, some users appreciate Al's original location, but others find their taste to be subpar and the portion size to be small for the price.
• There are mixed reviews about Al's, with some comparing its giardiniera to tasting unpleasant.

Portillo's

• Some users express surprise at the ranking of Portillo's, mentioning that many unfairly criticize the chain.
• A user mentions enjoying the cheese beef at Portillo's and praises the food quality.

Others (mentioned in comments but not in the top picks)

• Carm's, Roma's, Tony's, and Patio are recommended as notable traditional beef spots.
• Restaurants like Scatchell's Beef & Pizza and Il-Forno Pizza & Pasta are mentioned for their great giardiniera and Italian beef options.

Pros and Cons of User Favorites

Johnnie's

• Pros: Strong flavor, excellent quality, highly recommended by users.
• Cons: None mentioned in the comments provided.

Al's Italian Beef

• Pros: Original location appreciated by some, while others find it subpar.
• Cons: Some users find their giardiniera unpleasant, small portions for the price.

Portillo's

• Pros: Defended by some users, praised for food quality.
• Cons: Criticized by some for being overrated.

Other Notable Mentions

• Pros: Good giardiniera, traditional Italian beef options praised by users.
• Cons: Not the top pick in the user comments.

Overall, Johnnie's stands out as the top choice for the best hot beef sandwich in Chicago, according to the Reddit comments analyzed. Users appreciate its flavor, quality, and overall experience, making it a popular favorite among Italian beef enthusiasts.