Best Guitar Overdrive Pedal Recommendations from Reddit Comments:

Top Overdrive Pedal Choices:

Nobels ODR-1 Mini: Small, cheap, and fantastic.
Fairfield Barbershop/Modele B: Touch sensitive low gain, great for a variety of music genres.
JHS Morning Glory: Versatile with 2 gains, recommended for church music.
Mojomojo: Good boost with nice breakup.
Plumes: Affordable and versatile option.
Keeley Noble Screamer: Tube screamer and ODR 1 in one box, highly configurable.
Boss SD-1: Classic tubescreamer type, used on legendary tracks.
Wampler Triumph: Crazy versatile full range tube screamer.
EHX Soul Food: Transparent overdrive pedal.
Wampler Tumnus Deluxe: Tube screamer type OD with additional features.
Greer Lightspeed: Makes the amp sound better.
EAE Halberd: Highly recommended for its versatility.
Bondi Del Mar: Modern Bluesbreaker with characteristics of Klon and Tubescreamer.
MXR FOD: Recommended for more gain.
Boss Blues Driver (BD-2): Versatile overdrive pedal, liked by many users.
Klon Clone: Classic pedal for glassy tones.
TC Mojo Mojo: Can help achieve the tweed amp sound.
Ibanez Tube Screamer: Popular for adding mid-punch and crunch.

General Advice and Comments:

Price is not an indicator of the best overdrive pedal.
Overdrives come in various flavors, so the best one is subjective.
Starting with a Tube Screamer type pedal is recommended.
Listening to demos and reviews on YouTube is helpful in selecting a pedal.
Understanding different types of overdrives like Tubescreamers, Bluesbreakers, Klon clones, Transparent ODs, and All-in-one ODs.
Overdrive pedals can be versatile and suitable for different music genres.
Considering the setup, guitar, and amp when selecting an overdrive pedal.

Community Feedback and Additional Tips:

Congratulatory messages to a user for getting their first overdrive pedal.
Recommendations to explore looper pedals and essential gear for beginner guitarists.
Sharing personal experiences with overdrive pedals and musical influences.
Various anecdotes and trivia about famous songs and guitarists using overdrive.
Discussion on sound engineering techniques and historical context of distortion effects in music.

Overall, the Reddit community provides a wealth of information and opinions on selecting the best overdrive pedal, emphasizing personal preferences, versatility, and understanding the nuances of different pedal types.