Best Eyeliners Summary

Victoria Beckham Eyeliner

• Often described as top-tier and high-quality.

Essence Pencil Eyeliner

• Beats out high-end eyeliners, great for sharpening.

Asian Brands (K Palette, Heroine Make, Canmake, Clio, Merzy)

• Known for best waterproof eyeliners and mascaras for various eye types.

Milani Eyeshadow Primer

• Works great to keep eye makeup intact, even through tears.

Rimmel Liquid Eyeliner

• Soft brush for easy application.

One Size Eyeliner Pencil

• Stays on well without transferring, even for oily lids.

Trish McEvoy Gel Pencil

• Highly praised for its quality and performance.

Kate Japanese Eyeliner

• Non-smudging and reliable for long wear.

Huda Beauty Khol Longwear Liner

KVD Tattoo Liner

• A favorite go-to option for many users.

Urban Decay 24/7 Liquid Liner

• Highly recommended for long-lasting wear.

Rare Beauty Liquid Liner

• Waterproof with a great brush applicator for precise application.

Better Than Sex Waterproof Felt Tip Liquid Liner

• Lasts a long time and provides waterproof wear.

Sephora Waterproof Liner Pen

• Holy grail product for many users due to its reliability.

Bobbi Brown Gel Liner

• Considered undefeated by many for its performance.

NYX Epic Ink Liquid Liner

• Highly recommended for being sweat-proof and long-lasting.

Physicians Formula Eye Booster Super Slim Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

• Offers long wear and precision application.

Pixi by Petra Silky Eye Pen

• A highly praised HG eyeliner option.

Wet n Wild Breakup Proof Liquid Eyeliner

• Known for its long-lasting and non-smudging properties, great for daily use.

IL Makiage Black Card Eyeliner

• Rated highly for its overall performance.

Pat McGrath Eyeliner

• Known for its staying power, applicator, and pigment.

Elf Liquid Eyeliner

• Surprisingly good quality and easy to apply, recommended for its value.

Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Eyeliner

• A reliable choice for many users seeking long-lasting wear.

Truly Yours Eyeliner

• Offers a waterproof, long-lasting formula conducive to the humidity and heat.

Moira and LA Girl Gel Eyeliners

• Recommended for their quality and performance.

Forever Makeup

• A favorite product for some users, priced around $22.

---

Note: Several deleted and irrelevant comments were not included in the summary.