Summary of Reddit Comments on Best Car Rental in Iceland

Blue Car Rental

• Arguments For:
  • Mentioned as the best option by various users.
  • Recommended for smooth services, contactless check-in, and good condition cars.
  • Some users stated they had no issues with Blue and would highly recommend it.
• Cons:
  • Expensive.
  • Mandatory insurance through the rental agency.

Lotus Car Rental

• Arguments For:
  • Users mentioned positive experiences and ease of service with Lotus.
  • Flexibility shown by accommodating reservation changes due to flight cancellations.
• Cons:
  • May only accept debit cards.
  • Some users suggested that it might be overlooked in favor of Blue by the subreddit.

Other Recommendations

• Zero Car Rental:
  • Cheaper than Blue but still operated by the same company.
  • Users reported good experiences and flexibility with Zero.
• IceCar Iceland:
  • Favorable pricing compared to other options.
  • Contactless pickup and drop-off services.
• Local Companies:
  • Recommended for not requiring rental security deposits and flexible payment options.
• Hertz:
  • Positive feedback on convenient location and service at the airport.
• Geysir:
  • Mentioned as a good option by some users.

Insurance Tips

• Full insurance coverage is highly recommended due to potential high costs of damages in Iceland's weather conditions.
• Some users shared experiences of incurring significant costs without full insurance coverage.

General Tips

• Recommended to familiarize with the Icelandic weather forecast, road conditions, and safety resources.
• Advice on making early bookings to ensure availability of preferred vehicle types.
• Suggestions to use services like WiFi dongles over GPS extras.
• Caution against flying in on the day of a cruise departure.

Additional Information

• Advice on avoiding additional costs for seat selection and baggage by selecting fares wisely.
• Queries about credit card insurance coverage and ensuring adequate protection.
• Users shared experiences, recommendations, and comparisons with various car rental companies in Iceland.
• Mixed feedback on different car rental experiences and various insurance coverage options.
• Suggestions to verify equipment compatibility in rental cars like USB chargers.

By summarizing the Reddit comments, it is evident that Blue Car Rental and Lotus Car Rental emerge as popular choices in Iceland, with many users recommending full insurance coverage for peace of mind. Additional options like Zero Car Rental and IceCar Iceland were also positively reviewed. It's advised to book early, opt for full insurance, and conduct thorough inspections when renting a car in Iceland to ensure a smooth and stress-free experience.