Summary of Reddit Comments on Barbour jackets:

Pros:

• Barbour jackets are versatile and can be dressed up or down, suitable for various occasions and outfits.
• They are high-quality and long-lasting, with some users owning them for decades.
• Ideal for outdoor activities like hiking, dog walking, and commuting in different weather conditions.
• They offer wind resistance and water resistance, keeping the wearer dry and protected.
• Can be re-waxed for maintenance, making them look new again.
• Fashionable and classic, with a rugged British look that appeals to many.
• Great for layering and can be worn with different outfits during colder weather.
• Some models have practical features like ample pockets.
• Worn in various cities worldwide, showing their widespread popularity.
• Available in different colors, with navy being popular for urban settings.

Cons:

• They may not be very warm on their own, especially in very cold weather.
• Some users find them not as breathable, leading to feeling damp inside.
• Wax can transfer to other surfaces, like leather car seats.
• Require maintenance and care, including rewaxing and repairs.
• Might develop a musty smell over time if not cleaned properly.
• Quality has decreased in some models due to outsourcing manufacturing.
• Not suitable for heavy-duty work as they may tear or fray easily.
• Pricey when bought new, but second-hand options are available.
• Some users find the fit too baggy and wish for more modern designs.
• Wearing near campfires can lead to holes.

Overall:

• Barbour jackets have a mix of loyal fans who appreciate their durability, style, and versatility, while others have raised concerns about quality, maintenance, and practicality in certain situations.
• The perception of Barbour jackets varies among individuals, with some seeing them as timeless classics and others viewing them as overrated or outdated.
• Users recommend learning about the different models and their purposes before buying one to ensure it suits your needs and climate.
• Some users find vintage Barbour jackets to be superior to newer ones in terms of quality and construction.
• The Barbour brand is associated with a rugged, British countryside aesthetic favored by fashion-conscious individuals worldwide.