Winter Tires Suggestions for a 2012 BMW 535i

Reddit Comments Summary

• Subaru Outback Comparison: Some comments compared the 2012 BMW 535i to a Subaru Outback, highlighting the Outback's spaciousness and AWD capability, which handles snow well.
• Toyota and Honda Recommendations: Users sought recommendations for Toyota and Honda SUVs similar to the Subaru Outback 3.6R or Honda Pilot for snow and winter driving.
• Car Size Comparison: A comparison revealed the Subaru Outback is like a lifted BMW 5-series wagon in size, handling better than a Honda Pilot.
• Living in the Outback: Some users mentioned modification tips for living/sleeping in a Subaru Outback during trips or long stays.
• Car Comparison and Recommendations: Comments included comparisons of the BMW 535i to other cars like the Subaru Outback, suggesting models like the Buick Regal GS Turbo and discussing the strengths and weaknesses of cars like the Mustang, Camaro, 335i, and S4.

Pros and Cons

Subaru Outback

• Pros:

  • Spacious and has excellent AWD capability.
  • Handles snow well.
  • Comparable to a lifted BMW 5-series wagon.

• Cons:

  • May not offer the same luxury features as BMW or Mercedes.
  • Users may need to make modifications for extended living/sleeping in the car.

BMW 535i

• Pros:

  • Offers luxury features and performance.
  • Known for powertrains.

• Cons:

  • High repair and maintenance costs, especially for models with the N54 engine.
  • Some issues with distractions due to manual transmission.

Toyota and Honda SUVs

• Pros:

  • Toyota and Honda models are often praised for reliability and durability.

• Cons:

  • May not offer the same luxury features as BMW or Mercedes.
  • Performance may not match higher-end luxury brands.

Buick Regal GS Turbo

• Pros:

  • European GM design, not common for the Buick brand.

• Cons:

  • Limited availability within the price range mentioned.

Mustang and Camaro

• Pros:

  • Performance and engine options praised.
  • Nicer transmissions on the Camaro, better engine in the Mustang.

• Cons:

  • V6 versions may not offer significant power gains over V8s.
  • Fuel economy considerations.

S4

• Pros:

  • Robust performance.
  • Lesser-known issues compared to the BMW 335i.

• Cons:

  • Less fun-focused than American brands like Mustang or Camaro.

Additional Tips

• Use a layering system for winter wear instead of relying solely on a single heavy winter coat.
• Consider brands like Columbia, Eddie Bauer, and Patagonia for quality winter jackets.
• Opt for a good rain jacket and layering for versatility and warmth in winter conditions.
• Brands such as Duluth Trading, Carhartt, Berne, and LL Bean were recommended for durable and long-lasting coats.
• Take care of waterproof coats by avoiding fabric softeners and following care instructions to maintain waterproofing.

This comprehensive summary covers a range of suggestions and feedback related to winter tires for a 2012 BMW 535i, including comparisons to other vehicles, brand recommendations, and additional tips for winter wear.